Question 1

What taxes vary the most between states?

Accepted Answer

Income tax creates the biggest differences. Nine states have no income tax at all (Alaska, Florida, Nevada, New Hampshire, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Washington, Wyoming), while California tops out at 13.3%. Property tax rates also vary widely — from 0.27% in Hawaii to over 2% in New Jersey and Illinois. Sales tax ranges from 0% in five states to over 9% in Tennessee and Louisiana when local rates are included.

Question 2

Should I move to a state with no income tax?

Accepted Answer

States with no income tax often make up revenue through higher sales taxes, property taxes, or fees. Texas has no income tax but property tax rates average 1.60%, while Florida has no income tax but a 7% sales tax. Consider the total tax picture — income, sales, and property — plus cost of living, job market, and quality of life before deciding to move based solely on tax savings.

Question 3

How accurate is this state tax comparison?

Accepted Answer

This comparison uses 2025 tax rates from the Tax Foundation and state revenue departments. Income tax calculations use actual state brackets and standard deductions. Sales tax uses combined state and average local rates. Property tax uses effective rates from Census Bureau data. For a precise analysis, consult a tax professional who can factor in your specific deductions, credits, and local taxes.

Question 4

Do I have to pay state taxes in both states if I move mid-year?

Accepted Answer

Yes, most states require you to file a part-year resident return for each state, paying tax on the income earned while living in each state. Some states have reciprocity agreements that simplify multi-state filing. A few states (like New York) have complex rules about domicile vs. residence that can affect your tax obligations even after you move.

Question 5

What other costs should I consider besides taxes when comparing states?

Accepted Answer

Beyond taxes, consider cost of living differences including housing costs, utilities, groceries, healthcare, and transportation. Also factor in state-specific costs like vehicle registration fees, toll roads, insurance rates (which vary dramatically by state), and the availability and quality of public services like schools, roads, and parks that your taxes fund.

New York vs California Taxes

Compare Two States

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Resources

Total Tax Burden

Paycheck Calculator

Property Tax Calculator

States With No Income Tax